- Transportation
- Sustainability
- Placemaking
- Health and Food
- Design and Architecture
- Community Planning
- Bicycling
- Events
- Trending:
- Urban Green Space
- Cycling in Cities
Why I'm not voting for the Jenga Party
You can have a pile of fun with Jenga. If you're not familiar with the game, the idea is to build a tower of rectangular blocks and then make it taller by taking a block from lower down and placing it on top. The loser is the one who removes the block that topples the tower.
The Jenga Party has the same idea about running the country. So you remove bits of the public economy - the civil service, local government and so on - in the hope that the private sector will put in the building blocks that make the whole thing bigger.
You take away bits of social support - welfare, grants for community groups, support for voluntary sector networks - and hope that in its place will grow a citizen-led network that not only transforms society but raises funds for its own running costs at the same time.
You abolish quangos responsible for creating better places or regulating housing and hope that a new edifice will emerge with hundreds of new organisations doing their own thing.
The Jenga Party likes to talk about society and the environment and compassion. But its priority is to get rid of as many of those expensive building blocks as quickly as possible. What it won't countenance is changing the rules of the game.
Jenga looks like a way of doing more with less. But it always ends up with the same result.
* * *
So what will I be voting for? More than a year ago I suggested we needed 'a hung parliament, with a majority of members who are serious about addressing climate change and reinvigorating democracy, devolving influence and investment down to community level wherever possible'.
In the last few weeks that's suddenly risen up the agenda in a way nobody predicted. Most of the talk is about reinvigorating democracy; some is about devolving influence and investment; and hardly any is about climate change.
Whoever forms a government, these will be pressing issues long after the immediate economic and financial challenges have been addressed.
It might be tempting to put them off to another day while we deal with the deficit. I think that would be a mistake. If we're heading for even more difficult times, as Mervyn King suggests, then we desperately need governments with legitimacy as well as vision.
A first-past-the-post system that consistently puts governments in the hands of parties backed by a minority of voters is a recipe for disaffection. If we want a united country we have to do it by bringing together different interests.
Germany, the strongest economy in Europe, has lived with coalition and compromise with few ill effects. Scotland hasn't descended into a state of chaos since the election of a minority administration. Numerous local authorities have no overall control, but for the most part the bins still get emptied, the streets cleaned and planning applications approved. Life has an astonishing way of going on.
So I'll be voting for a hung parliament, not because I'm a convert to a single party, but because I think Westminster needs to relearn politics, starting with the noble science of compromise.
The first priority has got to be electoral reform, so all our votes count in future. The next has to be a serious effort to balance the short-term objective of financial stability with the long-term need to create an economy resilient enough to cope with the challenges global changes will fling at us. And the third has got to be a move towards genuine devolution of power and resources to the citizen, supported by strong and effective public services.
No party on its own can deliver this. Force them to work together and we stand a chance.
Other Posts by julian dobson
From Events in the Gents to Pop Up People - February 2, 2012
The Smoke & Mirrors of Laissez-Faire Localism - January 16, 2012
Why Local is Bountiful - and Can Change Global Systems - December 19, 2011
Why I Was Won Over by the Queen of Retail - December 13, 2011
Sustainable Design Requires Fun, Lively Social Communities - December 8, 2011
Sustainable Cities Collective
Urban Farming as a Successful Business (408 views)
Vienna, Austria Ranked As the Smartest City (295 views)
A Garden City for the 21st Century (248 views)
Lynne Barker Lynne Barker manages the development and implementation of the STAR Community Index and is a part of the ICLEI. More »
Kaid Benfield is director of sustainable communities and smart growth at the Natural Resources Defense Council in Washington, DC. More »
Chris Cheatham is a LEED Accredited Professional and green building authority who frequently speaks to groups and associations. More »
Jared Green is Web Content and Strategy Manager at the American Society of Landscape Architects (ASLA) More »
Rodrigo Herrera Vegas is a writer for for one of Argentina's main newspapers, La Nación, and a radio show host. More »
Warren Karlenzig Warren Karlenzig is the founder and president of Common Current. More »
Geoff Wilkinson is the Vice Chair of the Building Standards Faculty of the Chartered Institute of Building.i More »
Chuck Wolfe Chuck Wolfe is a lawyer, professor, and photographer who blogs at MyUrbanist. More »
- YOU
- TheCityFix - produced by EMBARQ
- Green Buildings Alive
- Kaid Benfield
- This Big City
- the polis blog
- Tyler Caine
- Centre for Cities
- Next American City
- Waverly de Bruijn Klaw
- Vanessa Francis
- Rodrigo Herrera Vegas
- Kristen Jeffers
- Warren Karlenzig
- Adam Mayer
- Foster Pepper
- Douglas Reiser
- Jim Russell
- Neil Takemoto
- Grown in the City
- ECPA Urban Planning
- Jovan Vucetic
- Geoff Wilkinson
- Chuck Wolfe
Wall Street Green Summit XI
When: Mon, 2012-03-19 08:00
Delivering the Green Deal: Building Partnerships, Tackling Fuel Poverty
When: Thu, 2012-03-22 08:00
Delivering the Green Deal: Building Partnerships, Tackling Fuel Poverty
When: Thu, 2012-03-22 08:00
Redesigning Local Services: Policy and Practice
When: Thu, 2012-03-29 14:15
A New Strategy for NHS Procurement: Securing the Future of NHS Services
When: Tue, 2012-04-17 08:00
Public Sector Pensions: Affordable, Sustainable, Fair
When: Thu, 2012-04-19 08:00

About Social Media Today








